Choosing the right color for your asphalt shingle roof is a crucial decision that can significantly impact your home’s curb appeal and overall aesthetic. With a wide array of colors and shades available, selecting the perfect option can feel overwhelming. However, understanding the factors to consider can simplify the decision-making process and ensure that your new roof complements your home’s architecture and personal style. In this guide, we’ll explore the key considerations to help you choose the best color for your next asphalt shingle roof. From considering your home’s exterior features to evaluating environmental factors and neighborhood trends, join us as we navigate the exciting world of asphalt shingle colors and empower you to make a confident and informed choice.

1. Consider Your Home’s Exterior Features:

  • Architectural Style: Choose a shingle color that complements the architectural style of your home, whether it’s traditional, contemporary, Victorian, or colonial.
  • Exterior Materials: Take into account the existing materials and colors of your home’s exterior, such as siding, brick, stone, or trim, and select a shingle color that harmonizes with these elements.
  • Roof Pitch and Shape: Consider how the color of the shingles will appear on different roof pitches and shapes, as well as the visual impact from various angles and vantage points.

2. Evaluate Environmental Factors:

  • Climate: Opt for shingle colors that reflect sunlight and heat in warm climates to help reduce cooling costs, or choose darker colors for colder climates to absorb heat and facilitate snowmelt.
  • Sun Exposure: Consider the orientation of your home and the amount of sunlight it receives throughout the day, as intense sunlight can cause colors to fade over time.
  • Landscaping: Take into account the surrounding landscape and vegetation, including trees, shrubs, and flowers, and choose a shingle color that complements or contrasts with these natural elements.

3. Assess Neighborhood Trends and Regulations:

  • Neighborhood Aesthetics: Look at neighboring homes to get a sense of common roofing colors and styles in your area, and choose a shingle color that blends in or stands out, depending on your preference.
  • Homeowners Association (HOA) Rules: Check with your homeowners association (HOA) or local regulations to ensure compliance with any restrictions or guidelines regarding roofing materials, colors, and styles.
  • Future Resale Value: Consider how your choice of shingle color may impact the resale value of your home, as neutral or universally appealing colors tend to have broader market appeal and may increase property value.

4. Reflect on Personal Preferences and Style:

  • Color Psychology: Consider the psychological effects of different colors and how they can influence mood and perception, whether you prefer calming neutrals, vibrant hues, or timeless classics.
  • Personal Taste: Reflect on your personal style and preferences when choosing a shingle color, whether you prefer bold and dramatic statements or understated elegance.
  • Long-Term Satisfaction: Select a shingle color that resonates with your taste and aesthetic sensibilities, ensuring that you’ll be happy with your choice for years to come.

5. Test Samples in Different Lighting Conditions:

  • Natural Light: Obtain sample shingles or color swatches and observe how they look under various lighting conditions throughout the day, including morning, midday, and evening sunlight.
  • Artificial Light: Assess how the shingle color appears under different types of artificial lighting, such as incandescent, fluorescent, or LED lighting, both indoors and outdoors.
  • Shadow Effects: Consider how shadows from nearby trees, buildings, or structures may affect the perception of shingle colors and adjust your selection accordingly.

6. Account for Maintenance and Longevity:

  • Stain Resistance: Choose shingles with built-in algae resistance to prevent unsightly black streaks caused by algae growth, ensuring that your roof maintains its appearance and cleanliness over time.
  • Fade Resistance: Select shingles with UV-resistant granules to help retain their color and vibrancy against prolonged sun exposure, minimizing the need for premature replacement or repairs.
  • Warranty Coverage: Consider the warranty coverage offered by shingle manufacturers, including provisions for color integrity, performance, and longevity, to ensure peace of mind and protection against defects.

7. Think About Energy Efficiency and Sustainability:

  • Cool Roof Options: Explore cool roof shingles with reflective properties that reduce heat absorption and lower energy consumption, contributing to a more comfortable indoor environment and lower utility bills.
  • Environmentally Friendly Materials: Choose asphalt shingles made from sustainable materials, such as recycled content or renewable resources, and opt for products with eco-friendly manufacturing processes and certifications.
  • Life Cycle Assessment: Consider the environmental impact of different shingle options, including their production, transportation, installation, and disposal, to make an informed decision that aligns with your sustainability goals.

8. Consult with Roofing Professionals:

  • Expert Advice: Seek guidance from roofing professionals or contractors with experience in asphalt shingle installation and color selection, who can provide valuable insights and recommendations based on their expertise.
  • Virtual Visualization Tools: Take advantage of virtual visualization tools or digital simulations offered by roofing manufacturers or contractors to preview how different shingle colors will look on your home before making a final decision.
  • Sample Installations: Request sample installations or photos of completed projects from roofing contractors to see real-life examples of different shingle colors and their impact on homes in your area.

9. Budget Considerations and Cost Analysis:

  • Material Costs: Compare the cost of different shingle options, including standard asphalt shingles, premium designer shingles, and specialty products, and evaluate their cost-effectiveness based on your budget and priorities.
  • Installation Expenses: Factor in the cost of labor, installation, and any additional materials or accessories required for the roofing project, such as underlayment, flashing, or ventilation components.
  • Long-Term Value: Balance upfront costs with long-term value and performance considerations, such as durability, warranty coverage, and energy savings, to make an informed investment in your home’s roofing system.

10. Seek Feedback and Consider Multiple Perspectives:

  • Family Consensus: Involve family members or household occupants in the decision-making process and consider their input and preferences when selecting a shingle color that everyone can agree on.
  • Professional Recommendations: Solicit feedback from roofing professionals, home improvement experts, or interior designers who can offer valuable advice and suggestions based on their experience and knowledge of design principles.
  • Online Reviews and Testimonials: Research online reviews, testimonials, and customer feedback for different shingle colors and brands to gain insights from homeowners who have firsthand experience with their durability, performance, and appearance.


Selecting the perfect color for your asphalt shingle roof requires careful consideration of various factors, including your home’s architectural style, environmental conditions, personal preferences, and budget constraints. By evaluating these factors and weighing the pros and cons of different options, you can make an informed decision that enhances your home’s curb appeal, energy efficiency, and long-term value.

Remember to take advantage of sample swatches, virtual visualization tools, and expert advice from roofing professionals to ensure that your chosen shingle color harmonizes with your home’s exterior features and reflects your personal style. Additionally, prioritize factors such as stain resistance, fade resistance, and warranty coverage to ensure that your new roof maintains its beauty and performance over time.

Ultimately, the best color for your asphalt shingle roof is one that complements your home’s architecture, enhances its visual appeal, and aligns with your lifestyle and aesthetic preferences. With careful planning and consideration, you can confidently choose a shingle color that transforms your home and provides lasting satisfaction for years to come.